.png)
How to Actually Sell Wine in your Restaurant - Wine Series #3
A well crafted wine list designed with intention isn’t the solution - it’s a prerequisite. Now comes the harder part.
Outside of your basic house pours, wine doesn't sell itself the way the rest of your menu does. Food, beer, and spirits carry their own momentum. Wine is less automatic, and it is the one thing on the table most guests feel unsure about. The outcome comes down almost entirely to whether someone steps in and guides the choice. That someone is your staff. If your team cannot speak to the list, the list does not matter.
This post is about closing that gap: getting your floor to actually move what you built.
Why restaurants struggle to sell wine
Three things are usually happening at once, and each one has a different fix.
The first is staff hesitation. Servers who will happily walk a table through six appetizers often go quiet on wine. The reason is simple: lack of knowledge and confidence. Wine is inherently complicated, requiring deep knowledge and experience to master. This intimidates people from learning more, intimidates them from talking to guests who may know more than them, and results in a wine list sitting on the table that gets glanced at once then set aside.The good news - you don’t need to be a master or a sommelier. You need a baseline you can convey confidently.
The second is guest hesitation. Research from the Wine Market Council found that 38% of restaurant patrons feel intimidated when ordering wine, while 72% appreciate guidance from knowledgeable staff. Wine is the part of the menu where guests are most likely to feel they know less than they should, and very few people enjoy being exposed at the table, particularly amongst friends and family. Faced with a long list and no guidance, guests experience decision fatigue and fall back on something familiar, which usually means the least expensive option they recognize, or a different beverage entirely. The two forms of hesitation feed each other: an unsure guest and an unsure server normally results in a house pour or a well drink, leaving margin on the table.
The third is management. Food cost gets reviewed daily and labor gets watched by the hour, but wine as a percentage of sales is often a number nobody is responsible for. Left unmanaged, it drifts wherever guest defaults take it. This is an extremely common pitfall given how many other things demand an operator's attention at any given time. We’ll touch more on this soon.
It is worth being clear about the stakes before going further. Wine is typically the highest-margin category in the building, and the upside from addressing these problems is measurable. Cornell research found that restaurants implementing comprehensive wine training programs saw an average increase of 23% in wine sales, and a well-trained floor can lift wine sales on the order of 10 to 20%. A study by Gultek and colleagues found a direct relationship between the amount of wine training a restaurant offered and the quantity of wine it sold. This is not a soft initiative. It is one of the clearer returns available to an independent operator.
Build confidence before knowledge
The most useful reframe is that this is a confidence problem before it is a knowledge problem. Your servers do not need to be sommeliers. They need to be able to speak comfortably about eight to twelve wines, which is a realistic goal within a week or two of focused effort.
Tasting is the foundation, and it is not optional. A server cannot describe a wine they have never tasted without sounding like they are reading the distributor sheet, and guests can hear the difference. Building regular tastings into the schedule is the single highest-return training investment you can make. Every by-the-glass wine and every workhorse bottle should be tasted by the whole floor, and the list should be re-tasted whenever it changes. These sessions should stay focused on education while remaining relaxed enough that the team actually engages with them. Work with your reps for this - not only will they bring the wine, they’ll run training sessions with real working knowledge.
Give the team usable language, not a textbook. For each wine, servers need two or three plain descriptors, one dish on your menu it pairs with, and one trade-up. A one-page reference that fits in an apron or is available on their phones is more valuable than a binder nobody opens. One practical addition that removes a real source of anxiety: include a pronunciation guide so that servers who do not speak French, Italian, or German can say each name with confidence.
Train through practice, not lecture. The fastest way to build the right reflexes is role-play. Run short scenarios where one team member plays the guest: the indecisive table, the guest who says "surprise me" and gives only a price range, and the guest who wants a wine that does not fit the rest of their order. This kind of rehearsal costs nothing and prepares the team for the situations that actually cause servers to freeze.
Build gateways for the common requests. Most guests order by category rather than by name: "a Cabernet," "something sweet," "a nice Chardonnay." For each of these predictable openings, the team should have a default pour and one specific trade-up ready without hesitation.
Recommendations that actually work
Once the fear is out of the way, a handful of service habits do most of the work. None of them require a script that feels like a pitch.
Lead with a question rather than a recommendation. The strongest opening is one that narrows the field without putting the guest on the spot. A simple question such as "are you in the mood for something light and crisp, or richer and rounder?" works better than any pitch, because it lets the guest express a preference in plain terms instead of committing to a label they may not be sure of.
Offer 2-3 specific options, not the whole list. Handing a guest fifty bottles is handing them a research project, and the safe answer to a research project is the house pour. Narrowing the choice to two appropriate bottles makes the decision manageable and signals that the server actually knows the list.
Recommend after the food order, tied to the dish. Wine sells most naturally as a pairing. Taking the food order first and then suggesting a wine that complements it gives the guest a concrete reason to order it that connects to a decision they have already made.
Tell the story. This is one of the more reliable selling tools and one of the most underused. A brief, genuine story about the producer, the region, or how a wine is made creates an emotional connection that a tasting note cannot, and that connection is often what moves a guest from a glass to a bottle. The story does not need to be elaborate. It needs to be true and easy to tell.
This is one of the most attractive aspects of wine, of course. It has a sense of place, a unique producer, and a real history. To the uninitiated, your menu looks like a list of hard to pronounce names which convey little to no useful information. But each of those names tells the story of a family, or a town, or a historical event. You need to share this with your guests.
Read the table. Matching the recommendation to the occasion is essential. You can make assumptions as a baseline - a four top of adults celebrating a birthday is a premium bottle table, a family with young kids probably isn’t - but always dig deeper and ask questions to determine how best to serve a table, looks can be very deceiving.
The principle underneath all of this is that good wine service leaves the guest feeling that they made the decision. The server's job is to guide them to a better version of the choice they were already going to make, not to upsell them just for the sake of increasing the check size. Your goal should be to help create the best possible experience for your guests with your knowledge and recommendations. They don’t know your menu, you do. They don’t know what items will be the best fit for them - you do, once you ask questions and make informed reads. Help them find the right items, and increased revenue comes as a natural side-effect.
The beauty of consistent wine service is this: the benefit holds even when the answer is no. A server who makes a recommendation, even one the guest declines, raises the guest's perception of service quality, because confidence reads as competence. Selling wine well is a form of hospitality for everyone in the restaurant, not just for those who order it.
Give the program an owner: the wine lead
The ownership problem named earlier has a practical solution that does not require hiring a sommelier. Most independent restaurants already have a server or bartender who gravitates toward wine, reads about it on their own time, and is the person other staff quietly ask when they get stuck. Formalize that. Promote them into a wine lead role.
Scaled for an independent operation, the role is straightforward. The wine lead runs the staff tastings, trains for proper wine service at the table, and provides quick tableside help when a server is genuinely out of their depth on a bottle decision. This is not the formal service of a fine-dining sommelier. It is a competent, designated resource that the rest of the team and the guests can rely on.
As a development move, it is well supported. A server who knows the list and can make educated food-and-wine recommendations within a guest's price range tends to advance quickly, and in more traditional rooms, wine service and the leadership of a section are precisely the responsibilities that define the captain role. Creating a wine lead position gives an ambitious employee a rung on the ladder that may not have existed before, which makes it a retention tool as much as a sales one.
Keep the structure honest and earned. A small hourly raise combined with a bonus based on overall wine sales can be a huge motivator. If they’re responsible for building reference material or doing anything unrelated to actually helping sell wine on the floor, Include a scheduled admin shift at a higher hourly rate than what they make when they’re on the floor
The service moves that lift the check
These are the smaller habits that put dollars on the check without adding a single bottle to the list.
Show guests the BTB math. When a table is ordering two glasses of the same wine, the most reliable upsell in the room is simply pointing out that two more glasses reaches the price of a bottle. A bottle generally carries a better margin overall than four glasses sold individually (bottle = guaranteed margin, glass = rest of bottle goes bad in 2-3 days), so guiding a committed table toward the bottle serves both sides. Framed as a courtesy rather than a sale, it almost always lands.
Offer the next bottle before the current one is empty. Timing is the whole thing here. A party with a 1/4 full bottle that's enjoying themselves is an open door; an empty bottle is a closed one, because by then the table has usually moved on to thinking about the check.
Mention to-go wine where the law allows it. This is a small detail with a real effect. In states that permit guests to take home an unfinished bottle, training servers to mention it removes the worry about not finishing the wine and makes ordering a bottle an easier decision. Confirm your own state's rules before building it into the standard.
Sell the course almost everyone skips. Most tables pass on dessert, and nearly all of them pass on the wine that goes with it. A by-the-glass port, a late-harvest wine, or a dessert pour offered the moment the entree plates clear is revenue no other prompt at the table will capture. In addition to your primary wine list, you may find success adding a small dessert wine / digestif section to your dessert menu.
Feature one wine per shift. "Sell more wine" changes nothing. A single wine that the whole team tasted at pre-shift, with one clear line to use, gives the floor a specific focus and moves measurably more product than a general directive.
Manage the system
The scoreboard is two numbers: wine as a percentage of total sales, and total wine contribution margin. A set benchmark is nearly impossible given how varied different operations are, so track trends. Track them weekly.
Lock in the foundation we built above, and maintain momentum and consistency. This means that building a new list and sending out a training guide doesn’t cut it. It needs to be a nightly focus, including features, incentives and contests, and on-floor support paired with regular training and evaluation.
The list itself sells nothing. Paired with a floor that can speak to it and a a staff that has ownership of the program, the highest-margin category in the building begins to perform like one.
The next post in this series steps away from the floor and into the bottles themselves: an operator's overview of the world of wine, intended to make the list you are selling easier to understand. Building a wine program and the training to support it is also work we do directly through our Beverage Development service.
Comments